Are you STRUGGLING with sibling fighting and jealousy? Want to stop sibling rivalry so that you can enjoy your kids again?
You are not alone! I have been hearing this from so many parents this summer. Sibling rivalry is at the top of their lists of challenges. Here’s a the first in a series of posts to transform your kids from habitual combatants to partners-in-crime.
Why the bickering? Why the jealousy? Why can’t they just get along?
SIBLING RIVALRY. Such an innocuous sounding name for something that causes us so many headaches and so much heartache!
(this post is part of a series “Stop Sibling Fights.” Download the whole series in e-book form here.)
We are evolutionarily hard-wired to seek connection with our caregiver. We rely on it for our survival. Connection for children means lots of attention. And when children feel they aren’t getting enough of it, they will try very hard to get some.
And when children feel they don’t have enough of us, they take it out on each other. Attention paid to a sibling is attention they aren’t getting. They think (consciously or unconsciously,) “If she weren’t here, I’d have mom all to myself.” They (consciously or unconsciously!) will test you to make sure they are still the apple of your eye.
Their need for attention and connection + the fact that children see each other as the reason WHY they are not getting enough attention = sibling rivalry.
Sibling rivalry causes bickering and squabbling, hair pulling and hitting, jealousy and whining (“It’s not fair!”)
You hear from the next room, “Mom!! He won’t give me back my guy!” They want you to drop what you’re doing and solve it.
When kids fight and you come running, each is hoping you will choose them and validate their worth in your eyes. “Dad loves me best!” And getting interacting with them you satisfies their desire for attention: “Mom’s paying attention to me. I am safe.”
Negative attention is better than none at all and during a sibling fight your attention is now on your child. If you do intervene, maybe you’ll rule in their favour proving that you love them best. If you don’t intervene, you’re pretty sure things will quickly deteriorate. (Coming up in the series: how to intervene)
(this post is part of a series “Stop Sibling Fights.” Download the whole series in e-book form here.)
As a parent and a parenting coach, I ask, “What’s driving the behaviour?” In many cases of sibling fighting, it’s a need for more connection and attention from YOU.
What can you do to get to the root of the problem? One-on-one time every day with each child.
Fill them up with attention and show them that you could never love anyone more than you love them.
Seriously. I know *you* know how important it is to have one-on-one time with each child. We all do!
But do you manage to make that one-on-one time happen? I know it feels overwhelming and life is so busy! Just for a minute think about how much time you spend refereeing sibling battles… Let’s take that time and use it to build connection with your child (and get to the root cause of sibling rivalry!)
Starting NOW make a commitment to yourself to have 15 minutes a day every day with each child. You don’t need to go for ice cream, you don’t even need to leave the house!
I have a magic tool for you. It’s called Special Time.
Special Time is 15 minutes a day alone with your child, immersing yourself in their world.
Build with Lego, play Frozen (they get to be Elsa!), have a pillow fight, make them into a pizza. (How do you make your child into a pizza? Roll out the “dough,” top it with pretend sauce with a big rub down, sprinkle with fingerfuls of “cheese” and other toppings. “Bake” and eat! Delicious and hilarious!) Roughhouse, chase each other, make each other laugh.
Special Time is like medicine or essential nutrients for kids. It’s not just a nice piece of cake for dessert, it’s the birthday cake that your favourite person baked just for you in your favourite flavour in your favourite colours with candles and sprinkles on top.
Special Time: No screens, no reading, no baking cookies. You are in their world of childhood, play and imagination. It can be really hard! Our ‘play’ muscles are so rusty. Put away your phone and don’t think about work or the To Do list. It’s just 15 minutes. You can do anything for 15 minutes!
My 10 year old daughter says that Special Time is “how I know you love me.” She calls Special Time “our game” and it’s different from one day to the next. Sometimes I make her into food, sometimes we draw on each other’s backs, sometimes we play with stuffies. She invents games for us like no one’s business. It might take you and your child some time to figure out what to do together if you aren’t used to playing. Don’t give up! (Download your *free* Special Time Guide here!)
(this post is part of a series “Stop Sibling Fights.” Download the whole series in e-book form here.)
If you want to reduce sibling rivalry and fighting, give your children the gift of YOU and your time.
Set your intention for Special Time each day with each child. If you have a partner and more than one child, you can trade. You might not make every day but if you try to make every day you will make Special Time happen on more days.
Sibling rivalry is caused by a primal need for attention and a fear that you love their sibling more than them. This concentrated super-power form of one-on-one time will make your child feel so loved. They will bask in the glow of your attention. They will be confident that their sibling isn’t loved more. If you do this, you WILL see a marked decrease in sibling rivalry.
Try Special Time for a week and let me know how it goes. Better yet, share with us on the Facebook page.
(this post is part of a series “Stop Sibling Fights.” Download the whole series in e-book form here.)
Next up: How To Intervene In A Sibling Fight
Sarah Rosensweet is a certified peaceful parenting coach, speaker, and educator. She lives in Toronto with her husband and three big kids (ages 15, 18, and 21). Peaceful parenting is a non-punitive, connection-based approach that uses firm limits with lots of empathy. Sarah works one-on-one virtually with parents all over the world to help them go from frustrated and overwhelmed to, “We’ve got this!”
Read more at: www.sarahrosensweet.com
![As parents, we all face challenges, but what happens when traditional parenting approaches don’t work?
That’s why my client during this call, Samantha, is actively transitioning to a Peaceful Parenting approach.
We’re talking through how those challenges can feel even more intense when your child is more sensitive and needs additional attention and understanding.
Join us to discover major tips for a more peaceful parenting journey.
Go to https://link.chtbl.com/Z_YOP4jb to listen to this episode now, and share it with a friend you know needs to hear it too.
[ID: Photo of child and parent arguing on a blue background. Audiogram reads, “Yeah. The fact that he brought it up again tells me that he’s got some shame around it and feeling bad about it. So we don’t need to bring it up in a corrective way. I’m going to exaggerate for the purposes here, but, you know, yesterday when you bit me, biting is not okay. We don’t bite in our house. We don’t want to do any of that. He already knows that, right? There’s no information gap where he thinks biting is okay. So the healing that has to happen is around he needs to feel like, back to the beginning when we started talking, he needs to feel like you still think he’s a good person and that’s why he brought it up, because he feels bad about it. So you can say to him and he says, oh, what did he say again? Remember yesterday when I bit you? Yeah. And he said, I’m a bad boy. So you can say there’s no such thing as bad boys. Mhmm, that is, yeah. They’re only boys who sometimes are having a hard time.”]
\#sensitivekids #sensitivechild #parentinghack #parenting #momsofinstagram #motherhood #toddlerhood #parentingtips #siblingfights #parentingexpert #peacefulparentingpodcast #parentingsupport #parentingstruggles #parentingshow #peacefulparenting #sarahrosensweet #peacefulparentingwin #gentleparenting #positiveparenting #raisinglittles #honestmomming #parentinglife](https://www.sarahrosensweet.com/wp-content/plugins/instagram-feed/img/placeholder.png)
Excellent (and much needed) reminder! Thank you, Sarah!!
Sarah, this is all very nice but I have a different experience. Reading your story caused my chest to tighten and heart rate to increase. My older brother taunted me continuously from as early as I can remember until I left home at 17. He forced himself on me numerous times. When I asked my mother to help me she put me off saying things like: “You started it,” “It’s your fault,” “Stop making things up,” “He was only teasing you,” “He wouldn’t do such a thing to you,” and the last time I asked her for help, “Well, you must have enticed him.”
I was a parent support group leader for years. One member announced to the group that her daughter was saying ridiculous things like, “Billy keeps touching me and he won’t stop.” Those words were some that I had used in my desperation to get help. Instead, the only thing I could do was run to a tree because he couldn’t climb.
One winter my parents left us home alone while they went to a party. There was snow on the ground and it was very cold out. I was wearing Bermuda shorts and a baggy football shirt as our house was always warm. When he lunged after me I dodged and he fell. He laid there and I thought I had killed him so when he started to rise I ran out the back door barefooted. I spent the next four hours hiding under a tarp covering my dad’s boat. The snow insulated the small space enough that I could stay warm. When my parents came home I waited until they were inside and crept in. Mom caught me and began questioning me… Evidently he assumed I ran to someone for help. He made up a wild story about me trying to force myself on him.
I don’t tell you this because I think your son is bad, I’m telling you this because I feel daughters’ voices become lost when hushed. As a child I learned early on that I had no value in our family. My words and feelings having less value has a profound effect on a child.
You don’t have to post this, you can delete it if you want. Thank you for considering another view.
Hello Jackie- I am so sorry that you had such a traumatic childhood with your brother. You should have been protected and listened to. Of course you- and every child- deserved protection and safety and to be listened to. I hope you have received some support around this. EMDR therapy is very effective for childhood trauma. (((hugs))) Sarah
I really do like the idea of special time but one of the reasons that I don’t keep going with it is because it’s so difficult for them to end after 15 minutes. It’s almost like I’m sending the message that I can only spare them 15 minutes. But 15 minutes every day when I get home at 6 pm and we start the bedtime routine at 7:30 and somehow have to cook dinner, eat dinner etc etc for each kid is a lot of time. Instead of filling them up, it ends in them being upset when 15 minutes is over. Everytime. It’s stressful and now I just don’t make a production out of it anymore.
Melanie — that is very common but that doesn’t make it less frustrating! Can you shift your thinking around this? If your child gets upset at the end of Special Time- that’s okay! You are giving them an opportunity to develop emotional resilience. And also giving them a chance to cry and process the pent up emotions they are carrying around (their emotional backpack.) Dr. Laura (my mentor) addresses exactly this issue in one of her articles about Special Time. I will paste the relevant parts here. I hope that helps. Don’t give up on Special Time! 🙂 xx
(from the article I linked to in the blog post)
10. End Special Time when the timer buzzes. If your child has a meltdown, handle it with the same compassionate empathy with which you would greet any other meltdown (“It’s so hard to stop…you can cry as much as you want, Sweetie…I am right here”) and give him your full attention in his meltdown. But don’t think of that as extending special time, just as you would not give your child anything else he has a tantrum about, like an extra cookie. Special time needs boundaries around it to signal that the rules aren’t the same as in regular life.
11. Be aware that often your child’s emotions will bubble up during special time, especially at the end. That doesn’t mean she’s a bottomless pit. It means she feels safer with you after this time together, so all those feelings she’s been lugging around are now coming up to be processed. Or it means that letting go of you brings up all those feelings of how hard it is to share you. Often kids use this time to express their upsets, so it’s good to schedule a little cushion at the end in case your child has a meltdown, especially when you’re just starting out, or when your child has been having a hard time. When the meltdown begins, just empathize, and give yourself a pat on the back for being the kind of parent your child trusts enough to express all these big feelings. Once she cries, those feelings will dissipate, and she’ll feel so much better–and so much more connected to you.
I really love this idea and want to implement it into our home. My hurdle is that I have twins who feel as though I have to do the exact same thing with one that I do with the other or it’s not ‘fair’ how do I show them that doing something different is just as special as doing the exact same thing?
Hard to convince anyone of anything 🙂 Why not agree to do the same thing with each one if that’s what they want? I would imagine they would get tired of it! You could make a game of it- exaggerate their desire in a playful way- to get them laughing about everything being fair: “oh we couldn’t possibly do THAT! I didn’t do THAT with your sister! It has to be fair! Wah wah wah!!” 🙂
Thanks for this Sarah! Any tips for helping a particularly jealous child from infringing on her siblings’ special time until or after it’s her turn? Especially if my spouse isn’t home to tag team.
Hi Amy! I would hold the space for tears around that jealousy. (Make sue the other sister knows you WILL get to her after you help her sister with her big feelings.) So it’s: “I know! You wish I could have Special Time only with you! You don’t want me to have ST with anyone else.” (or whatever resonates.) And then: “But you already had your time- now it’s your sister’s time.” And see if she can shed some tears about it. (Did you see the crying article in my FB group?) AND also see if there is something she would really like to do while you are having your ST (after the tears- or instead if you don’t feel the tears are there or if you don’t have time.) A special toy that she only gets during siblings’ ST? Last ditch- I’m not oppposed to screen time if that’s what it takes to get ST done with no interruptions. Good luck!
I love the idea of special time but I have 6 kids ranging in age from 18 months to 8 years old. 15 minutes a day with each child adds up! How am I supposed to distract the other kids while I am busy playing for an hour and a half every afternoon?
Wow! You are busy!
I will ask my peaceful parenting group for any suggestions of how to do Special Time when you have a lot of kids. My 2 cents is that you just do the best you can. Maybe you can make a schedule and everyone can get Special Time every 2 or 3 days. Also use every moment you can to delight in each of your children in the moments when you can. And do lots of family Special Time! Games, dance parties and pillow fights. Good luck mama! xx